"I'm STILL stumped on sign v. house questions!"
Yes, me, too. I know some astrologers use it interchangeably, I once did, too.
And there ARE certain similiarities, common ground etc, but I just feel that there is also a distinction.
For example, with my stellium in 1st house using the astrological alphabet (house = sign = planet), I would be considered acting and being like an Aries. Despite my Draco planets in Aries I don´t really feel like I am your typical Aries-character though.
But of course there are some shared manifestations. It`s tricky.
"So a 12H composite moon manifests.......in church?
"
lol that is one of the possible manifestations, yes.
BTW I don`t consider Neptune or Pisces or 12th house as formless, if we treat them for a moment as equivalents. The thing is Neptune in particular can take on ANY form, which is what makes people getting confused.
As for the 12th house it is so intriguing, we call it the "hidden house", yet that is not completely true. It is after all the house where the light of the sun is born and the first ray of sunlight appear. The real dark house btw is the 4th house, completely withdrawn from the light, deep under the surface.
the 12th house however, it is a bit strange, and has many possible manifestations.
For example, yes it tends to be a blind spot for ourselves, a planet hidden from our own acknowledgement, but not so from our evnironment. Usually people outside can see these planets operating in our psyche clearly, yet if we are not very conscious about what is going on within us, we might flat out deny this to be the case. At the same time however this very planetary agree is a ressort of energy, that is where we draw strength and power from, usually almost subconsciously, when we are getting depleted.
Maybe that is the reason for two other manifestations
a) it is the house of fame, curiously.
Much more than the 10th house interestingly. Not publicity, but fame status. (of course not every actor has a full 12th house, but given its reputation, astonishingly many public figures, representing some Zeitgeist, have it).
It has something to do with the strange simultaneious presence of both, privacy and collective presence.
Like one can hide in public. lol
Thing is often 12th house planets can become the carrier of some collective archetype, representing something of the collective psyche, or the collective tends to see that. (Pluto sometimes can act like that as well, especially in contact with personal planets). Composite 12th house can sometimes become an example of some archetype (reminds me of John Lennon and Yoko ONo actually. lol)
But of course usually we are just normal people, and no celebrities who become "idols" (in the very pure sense of the word; emanating an image that people choose to see; the 12th house has also been called the house of your personal God/ deity)
And another thing about it is that it was associated with conception or at least the prenatal phase, and in that way might also point towards karmic and past life stuff, hence the skippe step similiarity.
b) the other manifestation, that the ancient expressed as the house of monastery, hospital, jail etc. , well the principle behind it is that it is a house of privacy and solitude (though not loneliness). It is where we withdraw to upload our battery, to gain strength for facing the world.
People with a 12th house need time alone, to well as Terk in a musical described it "meditate to become one with their instincts" lol (pretty sure that was a subtle reference to something different
)
Oh and the ancients (and Vedics still do) consider it the "house of bed pleasures". lol
Well usually, if we are not John and Yoko, we are in our bed alone (or in case of the composite, just two people) and leave the outer world, out of it.
But really I think that is the basis of the 12th house, the area where we withdraw into our privacy and centre ourselves again and reenergize to then face the worldly areas again.
The downfall of this house really is a certain self-oblivion, that it takes time to acknowledge the content of the 12th house. It`s like we are drawing strength from something we are not aware of, even though others may see it clearly.
I mean honestly, I was shocked when people told me they could clearly see my Mars in 12th operating. I was not even aware of it! But when they elaborated I could see it, all the moments it showed its face clearly (no matter if it was a fit of rage as a 4 year old or so, because I could not read and could not understand everything my mom did or if it was me, being a shy kid really, suddenly get up before class and holding a spontaneous speech to make them donate all our earned money for an organization supporting children who had cancer). Nothing of that was done from a deliberate perspective. I had not thought about it. I had not even been aware of it, or how unusual it was. I did it by instinct, almost like some part of the subconsciousness took over and steered me towards this.
But point is, that is so much Mars in Sagittarius acting - putting energy into some mission. I mean it is the crusader mars after all. LOL
That in a nutshell is the 12th house for me.
"
I'm glad you consider the SIGNS in composite; it drives me batty that some astrologers don't."
It is debateable of course. Just like HOUSES are. in its nature the composite is simply an aspects chart, AND because it is derived of midpoints, actually we are dealing with an axis. So in fact our Moon-Venus is not in Capricorn, but on the Capricorn-Cancer-axis. And the 12th house, is really the 12th-6th house axis (one inhabiting the near midpoint, one the far).
I do tend to rely on the near midpoints though, especially in our case as the planets are so close to each other anyway. It would be probably different, if two people had opposing Suns, then it can get pretty arbitrary if we say the Sun is in Pisces or Virgo for example.
the signplacements always resonate with both, but for now I just think the near midpoint might be the more defining one. But I can be wrong about that of course.